June 15, 2006

Book 19: A Farewell to Arms

A Farewell to Arms
Ernest Hemingway

I have very mixed feelings about this book. I think that I would like to read more Hemingway, though I had to adjust to his very terse style. The plot is where this book really shines, starting slowly and picking up steam until the reader realizes they are in the middle of quite an interesting story, not quite the typical Florence Nightingale effect story. The only complaint I have plot-wise is that the ending is very abrupt. It's just about as abrupt as you can get. You've got the climax and falling action, and then whap! And the book ends. After absorbing the shock, though, I was able to sit and think about it a little bit, realizing that this kind of sudden stop could actually be quite powerful. After all, it perfectly mirrors the emotion it literally conveys.

I feel that a weak point here was the dialogue, which was really contrived and completely unbelievable. It made the characters, especially Ms. Barkley, one-dimensional and flat. The passages that were only prose soared and the insights offered were qutie amusing, Hemingway's wry sense of humor shining through and giving the book itself personality.

All told, the book wasn't at all what I was expecting, which was a hard core war novel along the lines of All Quiet on the Western Front. It is, instead, romantic in more ways than one (though not to be confused with trashy novels- it is never pornographic and at least in my edition all the swear words are blanked out). It engages the reader, though trailing off when the dialogue is prevalent, and overall makes for a good read.

Grade: A-

June 6, 2006

Book 18: 1776

1776
David McCullough

Ah, the day of Satan and here I am reading about American independence. I should say, however, that my review here might be tainted by the fact that the last book about the Revolution that I read was a Shaara work. This book, unlike the previous, is purely nonfiction, making it seem more distant than the novel, though it has its benefits (mostly believability).

All told, though, this book was a bit of a letdown. I expected a soaring, gripping narrative that could unite all Americans under a badge of patriotism. After all, the book is a bestseller and its author highly regarded. The book was not bad by any means, and I appreciated the lack of super-patriotic fluff. Its main flaw was that it was so hard to get into. I didn't really get interested until the seige of New York had begun, as the Americans were retreating from Brooklyn.

Also, the book seems to be somewhat incomplete. It focuses mainly on the military aspect of the year, with only passing references to the Declaration of Independence, undoubtedly one of the most pivotal events of the year, second or third maybe to the battle of New York and the crossing of the Delaware. Even the Christmas crossing is dealt with in passing. All told, the narrative seems to lack a theme, other than "it was the year that was."

I didn't sense many connections between sections, and while the flow was good within sections, the transitions between American and British points of view were completely scattered and often left me very confused. In fact, it took me a good 30 pages or so to realize that the book itself began in 1775 (although I'm still not clear). McCullough does a good job of tying in accounts of people who were present at the events, but unfortunately he occasionally takes the practice a bit too far when including absolutely unnecessary information that leaves the reader questioning its greater importance.

Things like this draw attention away from the main narrative, and though the book is a good work for those interested in a very general understanding of the military events of the year, it comes off as quite disjointed and limited in scope. It begins and ends too suddenly, even for a book confined to the events of a single year. I was hoping for more from the celebrated author.

Grade: B

May 25, 2006

Book 17: Alice's Adventures in Wonderland and Through the Looking Glass

Alice's Adventures in Wonderland and Through the Looking Glass and What Alice Found There
Lewis Carroll

What strange books are these. I don't think I quite get it. However, I will say that for a quick read, the books were entertaining enough, though they completely lacked a reasonable plot. In fact, now that I really think about it, they were quite difficult to even understand at points. It may be that I glossed over parts that would have made everything made sense, but all told I don't think I missed anything earth-shattering. To top everything off, Carroll excuses everything that happens in Wonderland as just a child's dream, kind of undercutting any point he may have made about an actual parallel universe of silliness, if only we would believe it. That's the message I would have liked to take, but instead he chalks everything up to whimsical fantasy. And this just as I was beginning to sense a coherent thread.

What Carroll does do well is wordplay. The books are full of puns and wonderful twists and turns of the English language that absolutely delighted me at every turn, being fond of such things. However, I don't think that the occasional bursts of clever fun can really justify the absolute absence of any semblance of plot or meaning. Wonderland is more like a ramble that occasionally peaks but usually falls short of a reasonable mark.

Grade: B-

May 20, 2006

Book 16: Lies and the Lying Liars Who Tell Them

Lies and the Lying Liars Who Tell Them
Al Franken

I will start out by defending my choice of literature. Quite frankly, I was in the mood for it. I was in the mood for something satirical and lighthearted, and I thought to myself, "Self, why not Al Franken?" I responded in the affirmative and spent my afternoon with this humorous account of the numerous follies of the post-2000 conservative movement.

I feel bad actually trying to review the book. I happen to agree with most of what Franken says (and I'm not good at numbers, so I can't crunch any of the tax stuff), although I'm sure that some of it is slightly distorted to fit his own agenda. However, I do think he makes a great point of specifically calling attention to numerous occasions that find our favorite conservatives actually lying, where it appears intentional. Many of the blunders Franken sights are from books by Bill O'Reilly, Ann Coulter, and Sean Hannity. While I can see how someone could unknowingly lie while on the spot, it's hard to defend these kinds of boldfaced untruths when they are published.

The book is a moderate expose that is played for laughs more than anything. I can understand why conservatives were so riled up about the book when it first appeared, but I think that the entire country has to settle down and get a sense of humor. In fact, I think that the point that the book makes most of all is somewhat unintentional: the current state of the media and political discourse in this country is dreadful. All it amounts to is lie-slinging and name-bashing all around, on both sides (watch Fox News or even MSNBC for a glimpse), to say nothing of sensationalism. In a climate such as this one, based on immediate and complete gratification, it is almost impossible for the country to have a reasonable discussion.

Liberals have often come out on the very wrong end of this quagmire, labelled traitors and anti-Christian zealots. When it comes to exposing conservative hypocrisy and playfully engaging the political climate, Al Franken impresses and entertains.

Grade: A-

May 16, 2006

Book 15: The Plot Against America

The Plot Against America
Philip Roth

Well, this book is certainly not quite what I expected. It's framed as a memoir, which must be popular as it's the second book I've read in this format in a while. I was expecting the main character to be a government official or something, but instead it is the view of a boy who is affected by a hypothetical historical turn of events. The events themselves, that of Charles Lindbergh's ascension to the presidency of the United States and the consequences felt by Jews, aren't entirely unbelievable.

However, the book loses a lot of its credibility when it reveals an actual plot twist, a conspiracy theory that could work in literature but which ultimately fails in this context. I think this is mostly due to the fact that the book reveals the major national events that occur in late 1942 in the form of newsreel recordings and before the narrator actually experiences them in his childhood. This is a major flaw. I thought that it was very sloppily done.

Here again is a book whose actual writing is quite good, but whose plot is just not working. I will even give credit to the original premise, and the conspiracy theory that motivates it. However, the way that everything jumps around chronologically just doesn't congeal to form any meaningful plot. A character will be introduced and then have a lengthy backstory. This in itself is not automatically destructive, but for some reason I don't think the method ever really worked in the novel, especially since many of the characters introduced in this way only serve very minor functions.

I expected a lot more out of this book and I've only heard good things about the author. However, I felt that this particular effort lacked any reasonable credibility and was not straightforward enough to be meaningful. I think I will try to look into something else by the author, but this particular book was sadly disappointing.

Grade: B-

May 14, 2006

Book 14: Sherlock Holmes: The Complete Novels and Stories

Sherlock Holmes: The Complete Novels and Stories
Sir Arthur Conan Doyle

I love Sherlock Holmes. Anyone who has known me for a while should know that. Spread across nine books in two volumes, this is the definitive collection of stories about the great detective and his pal Watson. The best thing about this collection is the way that Watson and Holmes are not just literary characters. Instead, they are two friends whose personalities complement each other perfectly as they race through England serving the cause of justice and, usually, the official police.

There are only a few shortcomings that I sense, and most of these are easily forgivable. For one thing, all but four of the adventures are narrated by the trusty Watson. This is by far the best format available. We get eyewitness accounts of the actual events, as Watson was often in the thick of the action, and his perpetual sense of wonder at his friend's great powers of deduction flows over to the reader, who is continually astonished at the feats of Mr. Holmes. The stories narrated by Holmes himself are relayed in his detached and often condescending manner, and work because it is in character but which still lack the sense of wonder we find with Watson. The stories narrated in third-person are simply not up to par.

The other great weaknesses are slight inconsistencies (in fact, two stories open up with the exact same incident, almost verbatim until the crime comes in) and a predictable plot flow. However, the basic structure of the stories cannot be faulted. Watson offers an introduction, Holmes or a visitor details a crime, the two go investigate, and there is a big reveal at the end, where all is explained. The stories themselves continue to amaze, and I am personally astonished that Sir Doyle could come up with so many distinct plot lines, so many distinct cases that glorify the mind of the great detective.

I have long been a Holmes fan, and my admiration for the singular abilities of this turn-of-the-century Londoner has only grown after consuming this massive tome of a biography. I feel like Holmes and Watson have yet to be discovered in the great annals of European history, like they embody the era just before World War I and the rise of modern criminology, as well as science. I only wish there was a third volume to consume, and I plan to return to 221B. Baker Street often.

Grade: A

May 1, 2006

Book 13: Memoirs of a Geisha

Memoirs of a Geisha
Arthur Golden

This book was very highly recommended to me by a number of people, and I think this greatly positive reaction set me up for a bit of a disappointment, though the book was by no means bad. It definitely has its strength. I think that one of these is its format as the supposed memoirs of an actual geisha. This gives the novel a very authentic feel, and I'm amazed at the ease with which Golden portrays the feelings of a young Japanese girl decades removed from his own time. The narration is usually believable and is only overdone at a few points in the novel, when the narrator seems to be a bit too self-aware.

The greatest strength of this book lies in its metaphors. From the very first similie, I was amazed at how well Golden employs unusual (but always perfect) images. Even when there are too many metaphors, I could only get a little bit annoyed because the comparisons were so good and so accurate. I think this is what really distinguishes the novel in a literary sense, other than its unique setting and subject matter.

I did have a few qualms about the book, however, and most of them lie within the plot, for Golden's writing actually is quite good. I think that parts of it were kind of stretched beyond believability, given the fact that the world of the geishas was supposed to be so cutthroat. How was it that Chiyo/Sayuri actually did manage to succeed? Interestingly enough, the most exaggerated character, Hatsumomo, was the most believable. She is the embodiment of evil and plays her part quite well, even managing to disappear in a fit of madness. Well played.

I suppose that some of the miraculous saving graces that Chiyo/Sayuri encounters would be believable when viewed through a somewhat cynical lens, that random fortune just happens to favor some. But it is this that makes me frustrated with the novel. The main character just isn't very likeable for me. I think that the entire premise of being a geisha is stupid, and that she spends too much of the novel simply guided by the forces around her rather than acting. When she finally takes matters into her own hands, the decision is a bad one (backstabbing a good friend who saved her life because of a childhood whimsy), greatly frustrating me when I was just starting to think that she was not so bad. I would have much preferred the novel to stick to the story of thwarting Hatsumomo.

All told, this book was worth reading and I would like to see some of Golden's other work. He just has a few basic construction problems, I think, but his talent is obvious. It could, of course, be the subject matter as well. Given this I will be easy on him, granting that personal taste is a big factor in my enjoyment of the novel.

Grade: B

April 28, 2006

Book 12: The Glorious Cause

The Glorious Cause
Jeff Shaara

Well, I meant to do this review right after I finished, but I was too tired. Then I decided to do it yesterday, a plan which would have worked well until my Dad cut the phone line. Oh, well, here it is. Maybe I'll get better as time gets on and post these right when I finish the book. Anyways, onwards!

I love Jeff Shaara. I've now taken it into my head to be sure that I read everything he's ever written, and that he has a definite presence in my will-be library one day. While I definitely enjoyed this book, I couldn't help but compare it to the other book of his I've read (To the Last Man), with the two covering dynamically different wars. For one thing, this book is written through the eyes of commanders, which makes more sense given the kind of warfare that emerged in World War I (being so different than anything prior). This is excellent for getting an idea of who Washington, Cornwallis, and other men truly were, but it also makes the novel somewhat formal and precocious, with no real regard for how it felt for the soldiers, always a concern of mine.

I understand that speech was very formal among the elites during the American Revolution, but the speech used in the book is quite formal, with Washington speaking the exact same way as Cornwallis. I'm not sure this would have happened in reality. However, this served to illuminate the difference with Daniel Morgan and Mad Anthony Wayne, who spoke differently, so I'm kind of split on how I feel about it. What Shaara has done well is painted a good picture of the main arenas of the Revolution, and how it might have felt for the commanders as they fought a strange new kind of war.

Shaara is best at painting realistic portraits of battle, and I can say that, having read this novel, I have a much better idea of the military happenings of the American Revolution. Actually, I kind of want to read more about it now, to see if William Howe was really as bad as Shaara paints him, and to see more clearly how exactly Cornwallis was trapped at Yorktown. All told, Shaara does a great job of illuminating a war so distant and yet so important to our national memory, personalizing George Washington and doing much to explain just why he deserves the title "father of our country."

Grade: A

April 7, 2006

Book 11: A Rumor of War

A Rumor of War
Philip Caputo

This is a very good book. This is the memoir of Philip Caputo, a lieutenant in the Marines during the Vietnam War. His story is odd, as he managed to be both one of the first Marines in Vietnam and was evacuated by helicopter in Saigon's final days, although by then he was a civilian. The book is interesting because it reflects Caputo's changing opinions of the war in a way that mirror the impressions of the nation during these conflicts (coughIraq). It was written after Caputo had seen combat, but the book was begun only a year after he left. Though the book gets preachy in parts (and here I am thinking of All Quiet on the Western Front, which definitely benefits thematically from its author's removal from the war by a decade), it still maintains a raw honesty.

Caputo is brutally honest, in fact, and the book will likely turn you against Vietnam and war in general. Here is another story about an enthusiastic young band of soldiers turned into weary veterans in the course of just a few months. Caputo does an excellent job of illuminating the theme of lost innocence, and for someone looking for an idea about the actual conditions of Vietnam in the lucid prose of a veteran, this book is it.

Grade: A

April 5, 2006

Book 10: The Magic Lantern

The Magic Lantern
Timothy Garton Ash

Well, this book is very interesting for several different reasons. It is a semi-hands-on account of the events in several major East European cities right as the revolutions against Communism were taking place. Ash was present in Poland for the monumental elections where Solidarity took control of the country and the Party was forced to cede much of its power. He was in Budapest where Party officials agreed to hold a funeral for a fallen resistance leader, acknowledging the needs of the Hungarian people for more open government. This soon followed. Ash was there when the wall fell and when East Germans streamed into Berlin to...shop. He was also the only foreigner to be present at the Czech Forum meetings in an old theater in Prague, given an insider's view of the organization of the resistance. Given all of this, it is bound to be an interesting, unique book.

That said, though, it is not without its major faults. Ash tends to change tense in his accounts, which read very rapidly, perhaps capturing the mood of the times but leaving the reader stranded. If you miss a paragraph in this book, the next seven won't make any sense. That is, if you were able to make sense of them at all. It is very hard to follow Ash's book if you are not very familiar with the events taking place already. That said, I believe it would be a valuable resource for future scholars studying the citizens' movements that were able to enact change across the region, but as an outsider I felt very lost throughout most of the book.

Ash also has a nasty habit of tooting his own horn a bit too much for my particular liking. He makes an overly extensive note that he was the only foreigner allowed into the Forum meetings in Prague, and while this makes him invaluable to any Western study of the events of 1989, he doesn't have to recognize that so overtly in his writing. We get it, his position is unique. I may revisit his account one day when I know more about the intricate workings of the movements of 1989, but until then the book is a primary source floating on an unknown sea.

Grade: B-