The Blackwater
Lightship
Colm Tóibín
Colm Tóibín is certainly aware of
the assertion that all unhappy families are unhappy in their own way, and in The Blackwater Lightship he presents one
that is marred by over fifteen years of resentment. This is a novel about
understanding and forgiveness, a well-written book that explores the ways in
which the past can haunt us and how it continually affects who we are at the
present. One of the risks run in presenting a story populated (by definition)
with people who harbor a deep sense of having been wronged is that such
characters- and, indeed, such people- are often cold and unlikable, which is
often the case in this novel. Main character Helen is vividly realistic, for
example, and as her backstory is carefully revealed it becomes obvious that
Tóibín has put a great deal of thought into creating his characters. She is not,
however, terribly likable, and none of the characters who are stuck together
for this long weekend can provide any real comic relief- or even a break from
the resentment that comes to dominate the book. Some authors are able to create
powerful narratives despite a lack of lighter moments (like Cormac McCarthy in The Road), but the characters in The Blackwater Lightship are often
simply being rude and petty, perhaps simply for the sake of doing so; by the
time the inevitable redemption begins to come around, readers may not care what
happens to these petty people.
This is not to say that The Blackwater Lightship is without its
merits, however. Any one of these characters could have sprung directly from
real life, and the tangled web of the past has been slowly and deliberately
constructed to make them who they are. And as cliché as the scenario (a group
with a complicated history, plus newcomers from a different world, are forced
to spend the weekend together) is, the undercurrents that run throughout the
book make it unique and give it its own vibrant feeling. Tóibín's prose is
simple and exact, relating what's there and not relying on fancy language to
create or maintain assumptions: the characters and the situation speak for
themselves. Though it's not always pleasant and can rely a bit heavily on
well-tread literary ground, The
Blackwater Lightship is a well-written glimpse into the lives of a group of
realistic and thoroughly understood characters that provides insight on the
power and consequences of unrepentant, raging resentment.
Grade: B+
No comments:
Post a Comment