Astoria
to Zion: 26 Stories of Risk and Abandon from Ecotone's
First Decade
Edited
by Ben Fountain
According
to editor Ben Fountain's introduction, the stories in Astoria
to Zion are all included (at
least in part) for their examinations of the idea of place. Though
this stated theme is not always evident in each of the collection's
26 tales, many do explore the varied meanings of physical (or even
mental) location and presence, whether as an anchor or as a
jumping-off point for further musing. The most successful works are,
unsurprisingly, those that are most inextricably linked to their
locales and those that embrace plot as a way to move story,
characters, and readers alike along the path to a conclusion, however
inconclusive. Several authors, however, fall into the quintessential
trap of modern literary fiction, refusing to knit their observations
into something meaningful and, in the process, forsaking interest for
the sake of creating art that, without sustaining the audience's
interest, becomes meaningless. This makes the collection somewhat
uneven, as runs of two or three engaging stories are inevitably cut
short by a dull foray into the worst kind of litfic. As a whole, the
balance tips ever so slightly, and ever so precariously, to the good,
meaning that the book may be best enjoyed in small doses, as the
reader is unsure from one entry to the next what type of experience
lies ahead.
It
is to Fountain's credit that the collection embraces standout fiction
that manages to be both literary and, in a word, interesting,
providing a platform for many talented writers to consider how we
alter, and are altered by, the places we inhabit, visit, and abandon.
I've read Kevin Brockmeier's "The Year of Silence" a few
times before, but its inclusion here invited me to revisit it in a
different light, allowing it to resonate with me in a way it hadn't
before. This, indeed, is the power of a good anthology, where the
theme enhances already excellent stories by inviting reconsideration
and a providing a particular frame of reference. Likewise, Astoria
to Zion's best historical
fiction (the stories by George Makana Clark, Miha Mazzini, David
Means, and Ben Stroud) works on several levels, asking readers to
think deeply about the meanings and ramifications of both temporal
and physical location while vividly depicting relatable visions of
the past. Nor does the general focus on location inhibit authors from
exploring their ideas in variegated ways. Benjamin Percy, Rick Bass,
and Kevin Wilson all set their stories in snowy forests, but each
tackles it is a unique way; the settings, while similar, evolve in
these skilled hands and come to represent something much more than a
story's incidental location.
While
each of the authors at least nominally relies on a set idea of place,
some are more wedded to the concept than others; even the better
stories that employ a more tenuous connection to locale, such as Bill
Roorbach and Lauren Groff, somehow pay tribute to its importance.
Indeed, the collection's least successful offerings are those that
feel untethered while struggling to define their settings, motivate
their characters, and/or embrace the power and near necessity of
plot. Contrast this with its most moving stories, which carry great
depth and resonate beyond their final pages; it is no coincidence, I
Think, that all rely on movement and change, whether positive or
negative. Something happens in these stories, and it happens
somewhere, as the book's theme would imply. Astoria to Zion
is an interesting microcosm of modern short fiction, with its best
stories evenly matched or exceeding the very best of the field and
its worst embodying its most unwelcome trends; in the end, its great
pleasures exceed, however tentatively, its perilous pitfalls.
Grade:
B
No comments:
Post a Comment