Upgraded: A
Cyborg Anthology
Edited
by Neil Clarke
All
short-story anthologies are, by nature, hit-and-miss propositions;
within every collection, be it the work of a single author, a
thematic group, or a "best of" collection, each tale will
affect each
reader differently. Even with that in mind, however, I found the
variance within Upgraded
to be greater than in many anthologies. I suspect that this may be
due, at least in part, to the broad spectrum of stories that fall
under its surprisingly vague "cyborg" theme. Indeed, the
collection's breadth is its greatest strength, and
I appreciated
the opportunity to read widely across science fiction subgenres,
finding that the hits and misses weren't confined to single styles,
themes, or interpretations of who-
or what-
cyborgs might be. In this way, the collection pleasantly
challenged
my own assumptions; I encountered brilliant stories in genres that I
usually shrug off and found myself disappointed in stories that I
would have otherwise expected to love. The collection has it all,
from the galaxy-spanning space opera and dystopian cyberpunk
nightmares you'd expect to less stereotypical intimate personal
monologues and even a wholly satisfying mystery
(Ken
Liu's "The Regular") that wouldn't feel horribly out of
place in a modern detective anthology.
For
all of its inherent variety, however, Upgraded
isn't constructed in a way that efficiently exploits the stories'
similarities and differences. Recycled themes show up erratically and
seemingly without purpose,
and the vast gulf between adjoining stories often creates an
unwelcome sense of whiplash, particularly when stories engaging
similar themes (or even similar interpretations of the term "cyborg")
appear too closely together.
Similarly,
I often found that the stronger of two (or more) similar stories was
placed first, making the following efforts pale in comparison.
Much
of this is based on my subjective reading experience, but the
collection's sometimes uneven structure seems to invite
and encourage the kind of direct comparisons that highlight stories'
relative strengths and weaknesses. The best and worst stories may
starkly stand out against
the background, but the background itself becomes dull and
ill-defined in
the process.
Overall,
it
is disappointing and distracting to be flung violently between
stories that effortlessly immerse readers in the chosen context and
those that remain
unsettled even
after ten or twenty pages.
Much
as the stories explore strikingly different interpretations of the
technology behind, and the
meaning(s)
of, the integration of machine and biological parts, there is a
significant gap between those that immerse readers immediately and
those that rely heavily on the authors' presumption of readers'
preexisting familiarity with various tropes. At times, it is
difficult to determine who the target audience is: while devoted
science fiction fans will certainly find much to love (and to stretch
the boundaries of the meaning and possibilities of the genre as
broadly constructed, which is not unimportant when
considering the
background static of the current Hugo debacle), too many stories are
unclear even to readers accustomed to the genre's most popular,
well-worn conceptions. Likewise, I was impressed by the balance
between stories that stressed a gee
whiz
element, focusing on the technology, and those that focused more
narrowly on personal lived experience and/or more broadly on themes
as important as the meaning of humanity and the gains and losses
engendered by fusing biology and technology. Plenty of the
collection's authors are eager to pose the questions and provide a
framework for exploring them; thankfully, few become too pedantic in
offering answers. Upgraded
may
be a bit frustrating when considering its harsh transitions and
uneven pacing, but its theme is coherent and there is much to be
admired within, in the shape of a
wide range of quality fictional gems waiting to be discovered by the
right readers.
Grade:
B
No comments:
Post a Comment